La propiedad privada ante el interés público, caso del cerro de 'la Bufa' de Guanajuato

AutorTeresita Rendón Huerta Barrera
Páginas173-190
!∀#∃!∀%&∋()∗+∀!%,!∀#∃%&∋%( #)∋∗!+#!∀# &#,−∗.!∀/ 0/1/2)!+# !∀#&#,−∗3 !4∗56∋/,% !7!8∗9/#&) ∗3!:)/0#& 1/+%+!+#!8 ;%)%<;%∋ ∗!=!>?∗!≅3!Α∗ .!≅!ΒΧ∆≅≅Ε
≅ΦΓ
!∀#∃%&∃∋()∀)#∃%∋∗∀)∀#∀+,(#(−#∋+,(%./#∃01−∋2&333
!∀#∃%&∃∋()∀)#∃%∋∗∀)∀#∀+,(#(!#∋+,(%−.#∃/0!∋1&
21∀.&#)(!#1(%%&#)(#3!∀#045∀6#)(#74∀+∀84∀,&2
4(%(/∋,∀#5(+)6+#78(%,∀#9∀%%(%∀:
;8<∀%∋&=
>+,%&)822∋6+3#?3#≅−#Α(%(2Β&#)(#∃%&∃∋()∀)#Χ#−∀/#<&)∀−∋)∀)(/#∋<∃8(/,∀/#∃&%#2∀8/∀/#)(#∋+,(%./#∃81−∋2&3
∆3#≅Ε.Φ(/∋/#)(−#∃Γ%%∀Η&#,(%2(%&#)(−#∀%,Ι28−&#∆ϑ#2&+/,∋,82∋&+∀−3Κ3#Λ&+2(∃,&#(#∋+,(%∃%(,∀2∋6+#)&2,%∋+∀%∋∀3
Μ3#Λ∀%∀2,(%(/#Ν8%Ι)∋2&/#)(#−∀/#<&)∀−∋)∀)(/3#Ο3#<&)∀−∋)∀)(/#%(/,%∋2,∋∗∀/#Χ#<&)∀−∋)∀)(/#−∋<∋,∀,∋∗∀/3Π3
≅−#2∀/&#)(−#2(%%&#)(#Θ!∀#98Η∀Ρ#)(#Σ8∀+∀Ν8∀,&3#ϑ3#Λ&+2−8/∋&+(/3
Λ∋(+2∋∀#Τ8%Ι)∋2∀
:)/0#&1/+%+!+#!8;%)%<;%∋∗
∀/0/1/2)!+#!∀#&#,−∗3!4∗56∋/,%!Χ!8∗9/# &)∗
∀#∃%&∋%(#)∋∗!+#! ∀#&#,−∗
>?∗!≅3!Α∗.!≅
∃∃.≅ΦΓ=≅Η∆
%9:;<9=Ι#≅−#∃%(/(+,(#∀% ,Ι28−&#/(#%(Η∋ (%(#∀#−∀#∃%&∃∋()∀)#∃%∋∗∀)∀#Η%( +,(#∀−#∋+,(%./ #∃01−∋2&3#Α(
∀28(%)&#∀−# Α(%(2Β&#2∋∗∋−Υ# (−#∃%&∃∋(,∀%∋&# )(#8+∀# 2&/∀#∃8()(# Φ&ς∀%# Χ#)∋/∃&+(%# )(#(−−∀# 2&+#−∀/
−∋<∋,∀2∋&+(/#Χ#<&)∀−∋)∀)(/#Ω8(#(/,∀1−(ς2∀+#−∀/#−(Χ(/3#!∀#∃%&∃∋()∀)#+&#∃8()(#/(%#&28∃∀)∀#2&+,%∀
−∀#∗&−8+,∀)#)(#/8#)8(Ξ&Υ#/∋+&#∃&%#2∀8/∀#)(#8,∋−∋)∀)#∃01−∋2∀#Χ#<()∋∀+,(#−∀#∋+)(<+∋ς∀2∋6+3#!∀
+&2∋6+#)(#Θ∃%&∃∋()∀)#&%∋Φ∋+∀%∋∀Ρ#)(−#≅/,∀)&Υ#(/#(−#∀+,(2()(+,(#Ω8(#−(Φ∋,∋<∀#/8#∃%&∃∋∀#∀22∋6+Υ
∃∀%∀#Θ∋<∃&+(%#∀#−∀#∃%&∃∋()∀)#∃%∋∗∀)∀#−∀/# <&)∀−∋)∀)(/#Ω8(#)∋2,(#(−#∋+,(%./#∃81−∋2&ΡΥ#2&<&# −&
(/,∀1−(2(#(/,(#∃Γ%%∀Η&#,(%2(%&#)(−#∀%,∋28−&#∆ϑ#2&+/,∋,82∋&+∀−3#;∋#2∋(%,∀/#Γ%(∀/#+∀,8%∀−(/#∀)Ω8∋%∋)∀/
∃&%#∃∀%,∋28−∀%(/Υ#/(#2&+,(<∃−∀+#2&<&#ς&+∀#)(#∃%(/(%∗∀2∋6+#(2&−6Φ∋2∀#(+#(−#∃−∀+#)(#&%)(+∀<∋(+,&
,(%%∋,&%∋∀−Υ#−&/#)8(Ξ&/#+&# ∃8()(+#2∀<1∋∀%#<&,8# ∃%&∃∋&#−∀#∗&2∀2∋6+#)(# ,∀−(/#/∋,∋&/Υ#Χ∀#Ω8(#/8
)(%(2Β&#+&#(/#∋%%(/,%∋2,&3#≅−#2(%%&#)(#Θ!∀#98Η∀Ρ#)(#Σ8∀+∀Ν8∀,&#2&<&#<&+8<(+,&#+∀,8%∀−#Ω8(#(/Υ
)(1(#/(%#∃%&,(Φ∋)&#<()∋∀+,(#8+∀#&#)∋∗(%/∀/#)(2−∀%∀,&%∋∀/Υ#Ω8(#−&#∃%(/(%∗(+#)(#−∀#)(∗∀/,∀2∋6+3
∃>?>≅Α>:#1?>Β9!∀Ψ%&∃∋()∀)#∃%∋∗∀)∀3#Ζ&)∀−∋)∀)(/#∋<∃8(/,∀/#∀#−∀#∃%&∃∋()∀)#∃%∋∗∀)∀3#>+,(%./
∃01−∋2&3#Ζ&)∀−∋)∀)(/#%(/,%∋2,∋∗∀/3#Ζ&)∀−∋)∀)(/#−∋<∋,∀,∋∗∀/3#Θ!∀#98Η∀Ρ3
∀≅:ΧΑ>∆ΧΕ#4Β∋/#∀%,∋2−(#∀∃∃−∋(/#,&#∃%∋∗∀,(#∃%&∃(%,Χ#∀Φ∀∋+/,#,Β(#∃81−∋2#∋+,(%(/,3#[22&%)∋+Φ#,&#2∋∗∋−
−∀∴Υ#,Β(#&∴+(%#&Η#∀#,Β∋+Φ#2∀+#Β&−)#∀+)#)∋/∃&/(#&Η#∋,#∴∋,Β#,Β(#−∋<∋,∀,∋&+/#∀+)#2&+)∋,∋&+/#(/,∀1−∋/Β()
1Χ#−∀∴3#4Β(#∃%&∃(%,Χ#2∀+#+&,#1(#&228∃∋()#∀Φ∀∋+/,#,Β(#∴∋−−#&Η#∋,/#&∴+(%Υ#18,#1(2∀8/(#&Η#∃81−∋2#8/(
∀+)#2&<∃(+/∀,∋&+3#4Β(#+&,∋&+#&Η#]&%∋Φ∋+∀−#∃%&∃(%,Χ⊥/,∀,(Υ#∋/#,Β(#∃%(2()(+,#,Β∀,#−(Φ∋,∋<∋ς()#∋,/
&∴+#∀2,∋&+Υ#,&#]∋<∃&/(#&+#∃%∋∗∀,(#∃%&∃(%,Χ#/82Β#∋//8()#1Χ#,Β(#∃81−∋2#∋+,(%(/,⊥Υ#∀/#/,∀,()#,Β∋/
,Β∋%)#∃∀%∀Φ%∀∃Β#&Η#[%,∋2−(#∆ϑ#&Η#,Β(#Λ&+/,∋,8,∋&+3#>Η#2(%,∀∋+#+∀,8%∀−#∀%(∀/#∀2Ω8∋%()#1Χ#∋+)∋∗∋)8∀−/Υ
∀%(#/((+#∀/#∀+#(2&−&Φ∋2∀−#%(/(%∗(#&+#,Β(#−∀+)#8/(#∃−∀+Υ#&∴+(%/#2∀+#+&,#2Β∀+Φ(#,Β(#∗&2∀,∋&+#&Η#Β∋/
&∴+#∀22&%)#/82Β#/∋,(/#∀/#,Β(∋%#%∋ΦΒ,#∋/#+&,#8+%(/,%∋2,()3#4Β(#Β∋−−#&Η#Θ!∀#98Η∀Ρ#&Η#Σ8∀+∀Ν8∀,&#∀/
∀#+∀,8%∀−#<&+8<(+,#,Β∀,#∋/Υ#<8/,#1(#∃%&,(2,()#1Χ#&+(#&%#/(∗(%∀−#)(2−∀%∀,∋&+/Υ#∴Β∋2Β#∃%(/(%∗(#,Β(
)(∗∀/,∀,∋&+3
Φ9ΓΗΙΑϑ:=#!∀#∃%&∋()∀∗)∋∀&+,(!−./#0(#1&∋∀∋2&,(3∋2&∀#0&#∃∋(4∗5%/#&#∋2,(/#4#&∋5(4∗5%/#&#∋2,(Θ!∀
98Η∀Ρ3
ϑ!4&Κ#1∗&%!Λ)0#1∋/Μ%+&%!+#5!∀#∃%&∋%(#)∋∗!+#!∀#&#,−!+#!5%!∀/0/1/2)!+#!∀#&#,−3!456/,%!Χ!8∗9/#&)∗
+#5!Ν%(∃;1! 8;%)%<;%∋∗! +#! 5%!:)/0#&1/+%+! +#! 8;%)%<;%∋∗.
Ο#&#1/∋%!Π#)+2)!Θ;#&∋%!Ρ%&&#&%
≅ΦΣ
!∀#∃!∀%&∋()∗+∀!%!∀#∃%&∋% (#)∋∗!+# !∀#&#,−∗. !∀/0/1/2 )!+#!∀#&# ,−∗3!4∗56 ∋/,%!7!8∗ 9/#&)∗3 !:)/0#&1 /+%+!+#!8; %)%<;%∋ ∗!=!>?∗!≅3 !Α∗.!≅!ΒΧ∆≅ ≅Ε
∋+,%&)411∋Κ+
Τ5!+#&#,−∗!+#!∃&∗∃/#+%+!+#!%,;#&+∗!%!);#1∋&∗!∗&+#)!,∗)1∋/∋;,/∗)%5!)∗!∋/#=
)#!#5!,%&Υ,∋#&!!%91∗5;∋∗3!#ς,5;1/0∗!7!∃#&∃#∋;∗3!Ω;#!Κ;#&∗)!1;1!)∗∋%1!+/1∋/)∋/=
0%1!,∗)Κ∗&(#!%!5%!∋&%+/,/2)!,/0/5/1∋%3!∋∗+%!0#Ξ!Ω;#!#)!∗&+#)!%5!/)∋#&Ψ1!,∗5#,=
∋/0∗!1∗∃∗&∋%!5/(/∋%,/∗)#1!∋%)∋∗!%+(/)/1∋&%∋/0%1!,∗(∗!,/0/5#1.
∀#)∋&∗!+#5!∀#&#,−∗!%+(/)/1∋&%∋/0∗!,∗)∋#(∃∗&Υ)#∗!#),∗)∋&%(∗1!(Ζ5=
∋/∃5#1!/)1∋/∋;,/∗)#1!Ω;#!%Ζ)!)∗!∋/#)#)!;)!∋&%∋%(/#)∋∗!Μ#)#&%5!7!&#1∃#,∋∗!+#
5%1!,;%5#1! 1#! %∃∗&∋%)! ,∗),#∃∋∗1! #! /)∋#&∃&#∋%,/∗)#1! Κ&#,;#)∋#(#)∋#
+/1,∗&+%)∋#1.![/∋;%,/2)!Ω;#!1#!∃&#1#)∋%3!∋&%∋Υ)+∗1#!+#!5%!Κ/Μ;&%!<;&6+/,%!Ω;#
1;&Μ#!+#5!∃Υ&&%Κ∗!∋#&,#&∗! +#5!%&∋/,;5∗! ΧΦ!,∗)1∋/∋;,/∗)%53! +#)∗(/)%+%!∴(∗=
+%5/+%+#1]!/(∃;#1∋%1!%!5%!∃&∗∃/#+%+!∃&/0%+%!∃∗&!,%;1%!+#!/)∋#&Ψ1!∃Ζ95/,∗.
⊥_;Ψ!1/Μ)/Κ/,%+∗!#!/)∋#&∃&#∋%,/∗)#1!∋/#)#!#1∋%!#ς∃&#1/2)!#)!5%!+∗,∋&/)%!⊥Ν;Υ5
#1!1;! %5,%),#!,∗)! &#5%,/2)! %5!+#&#,−∗! +#!∃&∗∃/#+%+!⊥Τ1! #Ω;/∃%&%95#!%!;)
%,∋∗!#ς∃&∗∃/%∋∗&/∗! ⊥[∗)!&#1∋&/,,/∗)#1! ∗!5/(/∋%,/∗)#1!%! 5%!∃&∗∃/#+%+! ∃%&∋/=
,;5%&!Τ1∋∗1!1∗)!%5Μ;)∗1!+#!5∗1!,;#1∋/∗)%(/#)∋∗1!Ω;#!/)∋#)∋∗!&#1∗50#&!#)!#5
∃&#1#)∋#!#1∋;+/∗3!∃%&%!,;5(/)%&!,∗)!;)!,%1∗!#<#(∃5/Κ/,%∋/0∗!#)!#5!∗&+#)!5∗=
,%53!+#!5∗!Ω;#!∃;#+#!1#&!∗9<#∋∗!+#!;)%!(∗+%5/+%+!%!5%!∃&∗∃/#+%+!∃&/0%+%3
1∗9&#!∋∗+∗3!,;%)+∗!)∗!1#!Ω;/#&#!0#)+#&!7!,;%)+∗!)∗!−%7!0∗5;)∋%+!∃∗56∋/,%
+#!#ς∃&∗∃/%&3!∃∗&!5∗!,;%5!,∗)1/+#&∗#Ω;#!#1∋#!#1!;)∗!+#!#1∗1#∋#(%1!,∗),&#∋∗1
+#!/(∃∗&∋%),/%!∃&Υ,∋/,%3!)∗!1/#(∃&#!∃#&,#∃∋/95#1#∀#∃%∋&%∋.
ΛΜ#(!#)(%(1Ν&#)(#∃%&∃∋()∀)#Ο#!∀.#Π&)∀!∋)∀)(.
∋Π∃4(.,∀.#∃&%#1∀4.∀#)(#∋+,(%−.#∃40!∋1&Μ
3!∀/#−∋<∋,∀2∋&+(/#Χ#%(/,%∋22∋&+(/#(/,∀1−(2∋)∀/#(+#∋+,(%./#∃01−∋2&!!α+/,#!Ρ/#51% α
(Ε∋/,(+#+(2(/∀%∋∀<(+,(#∃&%#−∀#<(%∀#2&(Ε∋/,(+2∋∀#)(#∃%&∃∋()∀)(/3#≅/,∀/#%(/,%∋22∋&_
+(/#2&+/,∋,8Χ(+#8+#+(2(/∀%∋&#∃%(/8∃8(/,&#)(−#%(2&+&2∋<∋(+,&#)(−#)(%(2Β&/#)(
∃%&∃∋()∀)#∃&%#(−#≅/,∀)&Υ#Χ#)(%∋∗∀+#)(#−∀#∃%&∃∋∀#+∀,8%∀−(ς∀#)(#(/(#)(%(2Β&#Χ#)(#−∀
+(2(/∋)∀)#)(#2&+Η&%<∀%−&#∀−#)(%(2Β&#)(#−&/#)(<Γ/].
∀#!%,;#&+∗!%5!∀#&#,−∗!,/0/53!#5!∃&∗∃/#∋%&/∗!+#!;)%!,∗1%!∃;#+#!Μ∗Ξ%&!7
+/1∃∗)#&!+#! #55%! ,∗)! 5%1! 5/(/∋%,/∗)#1! 7! (∗+%5/+%+#1! Ω;#! #1∋%95#Ξ,%)!5%1
5#7#1.!β%!∃&∗∃/#+%+!)∗!∃;#+#!1#&!∗,;∃%+%!,∗)∋&%!5%!0∗5;)∋%+!+#!1;!+;#?∗3
1/)∗!∃∗&!,%;1%!+#!;∋/5/+%+!∃Ζ95/,%!7!(#+/%)∋#!5%!/)+#()/Ξ%,/2).!β%!%;∋∗&/=
+%+!∃;#+#3! (#+/%)∋#! 5%! /)+#()/Ξ%,/2)3! ∗,;∃%&! 5%! ∃&∗∃/#+%+! ∃%&∋/,;5%&3
+#∋#&/∗&%&5%!7!%;)!+#1∋&;/&5%3!1/!#1∗!#1!/)+/1∃#)1%95#!∃%&%!∃&#0#)/&!∗!&#(#=
+/%&!;)%!,%5%(/+%+!∃Ζ95/,%3!∃%&%!1%50%&!+#!;)!&/#1Μ∗!/)(/)#)∋#!%!5%!∃∗95%=
,/2)!∗!∃%&%!#<#,;∋%&!∗9&%1!+#!#0/+#)∋#!9#)#Κ/,/∗!,∗5#,∋/0∗.
!!Ρ/#51%3! Π%Κ%#53! Ψ%∋+2∋∃∋&/# )(# Α(%(2Β&# [)<∋+∋/,%∀,∋∗&3!Τ+/∋.! ∀#∃%5(%3! Ρ;#)∗1!>/&#13! ≅Ηχχ3! ∃.! ΗΦχ.

Para continuar leyendo

Solicita tu prueba

VLEX utiliza cookies de inicio de sesión para aportarte una mejor experiencia de navegación. Si haces click en 'Aceptar' o continúas navegando por esta web consideramos que aceptas nuestra política de cookies. ACEPTAR